NAPLAN & ICAS

Can You Fail NAPLAN? Is It Hard and Do the Results Really Matter?

You cannot fail NAPLAN. It is not a pass or fail test, and nothing we found links a low result to repeating a year or losing a school place. Results

TutorExel TeamPublished 10 November 202610 min read
Can You Fail NAPLAN? Is It Hard and Do the Results Really Matter?

You cannot fail NAPLAN. It is not a pass or fail test, and nothing we found links a low result to repeating a year or losing a school place. Results are reported as one of four proficiency levels, and the lowest, “Needs additional support”, is a prompt for extra help, not a fail. NAPLAN results matter mostly as a snapshot for families, teachers and schools.

This page answers the questions parents ask most: what happens with a low result, whether NAPLAN is easy or hard, and whether it affects high school entry, selective schools or the HSC. Everything below comes from ACARA, the National Assessment Program (NAP) website and state education pages, checked on 7 November 2026. Our overview of what NAPLAN is covers the basics.

Can You Fail NAPLAN?

No. ACARA reports results against proficiency levels, not a pass mark. There are four.

Level What ACARA means In plain words
Exceeding The result exceeds expectations at the time of testing Ahead of what is expected
Strong Meets challenging but reasonable expectations On track
Developing Working towards expectations Close, with some skills to build
Needs additional support Not yet achieving expected outcomes and likely to need extra support Extra help is likely to be useful

Our page on NAPLAN proficiency levels shows how the levels appear on a student report.

What if my child gets “Needs additional support”?

It is not a fail. It is a signal. The result describes one set of tests on one week in March. It does not decide anything about your child’s year, school place or future. Here is a sensible response.

  1. Read the report with your child, if they are old enough, and focus on what they can do.
  2. Compare it with the school report and what the teacher sees in class.
  3. Ask the teacher one question: “Which skill should we work on first?”
  4. Agree a small plan, such as ten minutes of reading a night.

ACARA’s parent page says teachers use results to find students who need extra challenge or support, and schools use them to find strengths and gaps.

Is NAPLAN Easy or Hard?

It is designed to be challenging but reasonable. ACARA describes the standards as challenging but still reasonable for students at that point in their learning. Most questions draw on skills taught in earlier years.

Two features make it feel hard.

  • The test is tailored. The online tests adapt to each student’s answers. ACARA says if your child finds questions difficult, they may simply be on a harder test pathway, which does not mean they are doing badly.
  • The format is new. Timers, headphones, flagging questions and typed writing can feel strange the first time.
Common worry What is actually going on
“Every question was too hard.” A child who answers well gets harder questions
“I ran out of time.” Each test has a set time, and the timer shows in the last 5 minutes
“I didn’t know the answer.” Nobody knows every answer, and the tests are meant to stretch
“The screen was confusing.” Practise on the free demonstration site once

So is NAPLAN easy or hard? It depends on the child and the question. It is meant to include some questions that most students find tough.

Do NAPLAN Results Matter?

They matter in some ways and not in others. This table sets out where.

Area Do results matter? What the sources show
Passing a year No NAPLAN is not a pass or fail test
Teacher planning Yes Teachers use results to find students needing challenge or support
School planning Yes Schools use them to find strengths and gaps
School comparison Somewhat My School shows school-level results over time
NSW selective high schools No The policy does not mention NAPLAN
Victorian selective entry No The department page does not mention NAPLAN
Some private schools It depends Check each school
HSC minimum standard (NSW) Not for current students NESA lists NAPLAN only for 2017 results

Does NAPLAN affect high school entry?

For public school entry by zone, we found no official source that links NAPLAN to enrolment. For private and independent schools, it depends on the school. Some ask to see reports, and some do not. Ask each school directly and keep the report handy. Our guide to NAPLAN vs selective school tests compares the two sets of exams.

Is NAPLAN used for selective schools?

No, according to the pages we checked. The NSW Department of Education places students in opportunity classes and selective high schools using its own placement tests. The Victorian selective entry process uses an exam run by ACER. ACARA states that NAPLAN is not designed to be a school admission test.

Does Year 9 NAPLAN affect the HSC?

Not for current NSW students. NESA’s page on demonstrating the HSC minimum standard lists NAPLAN only for 2017 results. Students now reach the standard through NESA online tests. Other states differ. In Western Australia, for example, Year 9 results can help with part of the senior certificate literacy and numeracy requirement, so check with your school.

What Happens in Different Situations

Situation What it means
Low result A prompt for support, not a fail
High result A positive snapshot, not a guarantee of anything
Absent on test day The school may arrange a catch-up inside the window
Withdrawn by a parent Allowed in some cases, such as religious or philosophical reasons
Exempt For limited English proficiency or significant disability

Our guide on whether NAPLAN is compulsory explains withdrawal and exemption in full. ACARA says participation by all students is expected, but parents may withdraw a child in certain circumstances.

Myths and Facts

Myth Fact
“My child will be held back if the result is low.” We found no official source that says so. NAPLAN is not a pass or fail test
“A top result gets you into a selective school.” The NSW and Victorian pages list their own tests as the route
“Everyone must sit it.” Participation is expected, but parents may withdraw in some cases
“NAPLAN is the HSC for Year 9.” NESA lists NAPLAN only for 2017 results for the HSC minimum standard
“You need a tutor to do well.” ACARA says students are not expected to study and advises against excessive preparation and paying coaching providers
“The old band numbers still apply.” Bands were retired after 2022, and levels replaced them

Why the Report Looks Different Now

Older reports used bands from 1 to 10. Since 2023, NAPLAN reports use four proficiency levels and a scale score. ACARA says this gives clearer and simpler information for families. The tests also moved earlier in the year, to March, and the scales were reset. As a result, a 2023 or later report cannot be compared directly with an older one. If a relative says “Band 6 is fine,” that comes from the old system. Our page on NAPLAN results explained covers the change.

What You Can Do Before the Test

Most of the useful work happens in calm, ordinary weeks.

  • Read together. Ten minutes a night helps vocabulary and comprehension.
  • Play with numbers. Shopping, cooking and games build number sense.
  • Show the screen once. The free demonstration site takes 20 minutes.
  • Say it is a normal test. ACARA suggests telling children NAPLAN is part of school and to do their best.
  • Keep sleep and meals steady. Nothing beats a rested child.

You do not need a long plan. Our NAPLAN preparation page keeps the steps short.

Questions Parents Ask Teachers

Take these to a parent-teacher chat.

  1. How did my child do compared with class work?
  2. Which question types seemed hardest?
  3. Is there a skill you are already working on?
  4. Does the school use the results to group students?
  5. What would help at home?

Teachers see hundreds of reports and often welcome clear questions. Their answers are more useful than any ranking.

How Much It Matters at Each Year Level

Year What the result is mostly used for
Year 3 A first national snapshot, and early support if needed
Year 5 A check on progress since Year 3
Year 7 A starting picture for a new high school
Year 9 A check before senior years, with extra meaning in some states

At every level, the result sits beside school reports and teacher advice. No single test tells the whole story of a child’s learning. A child with a quiet week, a cold or a nervous morning may score below what they can really do.

If the result surprises you

A result that is higher or lower than expected is useful information. Ask the teacher what they see in class. If the two agree, you have a clear next step. If they disagree, the teacher may have more detail, such as how your child works under time pressure. Either way, you learn something you did not know.

Why Schools and Governments Use NAPLAN

ACARA gives three main reasons.

  • Teachers use results to find students who need extra challenge or support.
  • Schools use results to find strengths and gaps, improve teaching and set literacy and numeracy goals.
  • School systems use results to evaluate programs and decide where to put support.

The public can also see school performance over time on My School. For a child, the main use is a conversation between you and the teacher.

How to Use the Result Well

Treat the report like a weather forecast, not a verdict. It tells you roughly how conditions looked on one day.

  • Read the whole report. The first page explains how to read it, and the last page lists skills students at each level typically show.
  • Compare with school reports. If the two agree, you have a clear picture. If they differ, ask the teacher.
  • Pick one skill. Do not try to fix everything at once.
  • Keep the tone light. Say “Here is what you did well” before “Here is what to work on.”
  • Look at growth. A result next to a previous one tells you more than a single number. ACARA says results from 2023 onwards can be compared with each other, but not with 2008 to 2022 results.

Talking to Your Child About the Result

Children read our moods. If we look worried, they feel worse. Try these words.

Result Try saying
Strong or Exceeding “You worked hard. I’m proud of how you kept going.”
Developing “This shows what you know and what we can practise. Let’s pick one thing.”
Needs additional support “This tells your teacher where to help. It doesn’t say what you can do.”

Never compare siblings or friends. A report is private.

When Worry Is Bigger Than the Test

If your child is very anxious about NAPLAN, you can read our guide on reducing NAPLAN stress. If worry spreads to school, sleep or friends, talk to your school counsellor or GP. Kids Helpline is available 24 hours a day on 1800 55 1800 for children and young people.

Next Step: One Short Conversation

The most useful thing you can do after NAPLAN is a ten-minute chat with the teacher. Bring the report and ask three questions. Which skill is strongest? Which one needs a little help? What can we do at home? Most families need nothing more than that and a steady reading habit. If you want to plan the lead-up to next year’s tests, our overview of NAPLAN preparation keeps it calm.

Conclusion

You cannot fail NAPLAN. The test reports a proficiency level, and even the lowest level is a prompt for support, not a pass or fail. It can feel hard because it is tailored, but a hard question does not mean a child is doing badly. Results help teachers and families, and they do not decide selective entry in NSW or Victoria, or the HSC for current NSW students. Keep your response calm, and use the report as a conversation starter.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you fail NAPLAN?

No. NAPLAN is not a pass or fail test. Results are reported as one of four proficiency levels: Exceeding, Strong, Developing and Needs additional support. The lowest level signals that extra help may be useful.

What if you fail NAPLAN, or get Needs additional support?

It is not a failure. It is a prompt for support. Read the report with the teacher, compare it with school reports and pick one skill to work on. ACARA says NAPLAN is not a pass or fail test.

Is NAPLAN easy or hard?

ACARA describes the standards as challenging but still reasonable. Most questions use skills from earlier years. The online test is tailored, so a student who answers well meets harder questions. That is normal.

Does NAPLAN affect high school entry?

We found no official link between NAPLAN and public school zone enrolment. Some private schools ask to see reports, and it depends on the school. Ask each school directly what it needs.

Is NAPLAN used for selective schools?

No, according to the NSW and Victorian pages we checked. NSW uses its own placement tests, and Victoria uses an entry exam run by ACER. ACARA says NAPLAN is not designed to be a school admission test.

Who sees my child’s NAPLAN results?

Each student gets an individual report, which goes to the school and then to families. Schools and systems also use results to plan support, and My School shows school-level results over time. Ask your school how it shares them.

Written by the TutorExel Team

Live online tutoring in Maths, English and Science for Years 2 to 7, plus piano and guitar lessons.

About TutorExel

Keep reading

All articles
NAPLAN Tips for Test Week: 15 Strategies for Every Test
NAPLAN & ICAS

NAPLAN Tips for Test Week: 15 Strategies for Every Test

The best NAPLAN tips are simple: sleep well, plan your writing, read each question twice, flag hard questions and check your answers at the end of each section. The 2027

NAPLAN Tips for Test Week: 15 Strategies for Every Test
Reducing NAPLAN Exam Stress: A Calm Plan for Parents and Kids
NAPLAN & ICAS

Reducing NAPLAN Exam Stress: A Calm Plan for Parents and Kids

The best way to reduce NAPLAN exam stress is to lower the stakes, keep routines normal and say less, not more. ACARA tells parents to reassure children that NAPLAN is

Reducing NAPLAN Exam Stress: A Calm Plan for Parents and Kids
NAPLAN in 2 Weeks: A Last-Minute Preparation Checklist
NAPLAN & ICAS

NAPLAN in 2 Weeks: A Last-Minute Preparation Checklist

With two weeks to go, do four things: check the test days with your school, try the free demonstration site once, revise light skills for 15 to 20 minutes a

NAPLAN in 2 Weeks: A Last-Minute Preparation Checklist
Happy student learning online

Ready to See Your Child Excel?

Join hundreds of Worldwide families who trust TutorExel for their children's education. Book your FREE trial class today, no credit card required.

Join Now→Free Assessment Test